Tag Archives: Pakistan

Building Women’s Chambers and Associations in South Asia

south asia women entrepreneurship symposium

Hammad Siddiqui, Deputy Country Director for CIPE’s Pakistan field office, contributed to this report.

To begin addressing the issue of why some women’s business organizations thrive while others do not, CIPE recently launched a project to build links among women’s chambers and associations in South Asia.

CIPE identified 11 organizations, from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal and Sri Lanka – and for the first time reached out to groups from India and Bhutan – to participate. With the assistance of long-time partner the Bangladesh Women’s Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BWCCI), conducted a diagnostic survey of these organizations’ governance, finances, membership, strategic planning, advocacy, services and other issues. The organizations were then invited to participate in a networking meeting held this February in Dhaka, Bangladesh. CIPE’s efforts complement a U.S. State Department program to build links among women entrepreneurs in the region, the South Asia Women Entrepreneurship Symposium.

CONTINUE READING

Unpacking Corruption in Pakistan

Pakistan is considered one of the most corrupt countries in the world. Transparency International’s recent survey ranks the country 134th on the Corruption Perception Index, with only 42 countries scoring worse. It is encouraging that Pakistanis now openly talk about corruption: according to a recent public opinion poll conducted by Gallup Pakistan asking about the most disliked thing in Pakistan, corruption topped in the list at 16 percent.

Various donor agencies have been working in Pakistan for many years on reducing the menace of corruption. Some major reform work has been done in the Federal Board of Revenue, the department that collects taxes on income, sales, and property. Under a grant from the British Government, e-filing of these taxes was introduced in 2005. That reduced the interaction between the tax officer and taxpayer and also said to have reduced the opportunity for corruption.

Having said this, many sources of potential corruption remain. For example, newspaper reports suggest that in the past four years, Pakistan’s five large public sector organizations lost Rs 393 billion ($4 billion USD).

Despite an increase in media reports on corruption, until recently the business community was reluctant to speak publicly about corruption that is rampant in other segments of Pakistani society. When CIPE started talking to the business community about its role in reducing corruption, the response of businesspeople was lukewarm. They were concerned that if they started advocating for reducing corruption, they might be penalized by the government agencies, and as a result might end up losing more money.

To help bring attention to the problem, the Young Entrepreneurs Forum (YEF), which is a part of Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry, earlier this year launched a corruption perception survey, funded by a small grant from CIPE Pakistan.

CONTINUE READING

Looking Back on Global Entrepreneurship Week in Pakistan

Our Youth is highly motivated, unaware, lacks counseling and guidance. Do not have access to information and available opportunities. Participating Entrepreneurs including some from Pakistan’s top 100 have agreed to provide mentoring, office space and training for start-ups and pool in some sort of seed fund. GEW provided an opportunity to bridge gap between aspiring entrepreneurs and other stakeholders. Now we have a roadmap to tackle the issue of low entrepreneurial activity in Pakistan.  (Kashif M. Khan / President / Global Entrepreneurship Week- Pakistan Initiative of Kauffman Foundation)

Global Entrepreneurship Week was never celebrated in Pakistan in a big way. Only last year, the Center for International Private Enterprise organized two major events in Karachi and Islamabad by engaging university students in a debate on “What it takes to be an Entrepreneur.” The Islamabad event was organized in partnership with Young Entrepreneur’s Forum at Islamabad Chamber of Commerce & Industry.

Throughout the year, the CIPE Pakistan team continued speaking about GEW in meetings with partners and at networking events. As a result, this year there were at least 20 events were organized in the country. Most of these events were initiated by the Kaufman Foundation (supported by the U.S. Embassy) and CIPE. It is hoped that from two events to 20 in one year will create a chain reaction, and GEW 2013 will be celebrated with even more enthusiasm.

I would like to talk about CIPE events and what did we do differently. First of all, CIPE events were organized in partnership with local non-profit organizations. This resulted in improving partners’ understanding about the issues related to low entrepreneurial activity in Pakistan, as well as building their capacity to conduct such programs independently in the following years.

The next significant aspect of the CIPE activities was the design in which, rather than listening to a panel of experts, participants shared their ideas on entrepreneurial issues and possible solutions for Pakistan.

CIPE also encouraged teachers from various universities to attend and listen to what their students had to say on the improvement of teaching styles and the entrepreneurship curriculum.  One of the most interesting events, in Peshawar, was organized in partnership with the Peshawar Women Chamber of Commerce & Industry and focused on the choice of an entrepreneurial career by girls living in Northern Pakistan.

To spread the word on social media, CIPE created a unique hashtag #GEWPK. In addition to photo sharing on Facebook, CIPE events were tweeted live and in addition to coverage in local media, a number of bloggers covered the events, including:

Fahmina Arshad

Zainab Khawaja

Ali Suleman

BSO Forum

Ahsan Umar

CIPE hopes that partners will continue momentum started during GEW and that next year there will be more independent events across the country.

Driving Youth Entrepreneurship in Pakistan

Last week the Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry ICCI joined the Center for International Private Enterprise and  Kauffman Foundation to celebrate Global Entrepreneurship Week.  Aiming to determine obstacles to entrepreneurship, ICCI gathered a large number of young entrepreneurs, established businessmen, and students to discuss key impediments to aspiring entrepreneurs.

Amid their discussion, many participants voiced the opinion that the main objective should be to foster an entrepreneurial culture among youth.  CIPE Deputy Country Director Hammad Siddiqui asserts that the only way Pakistan can take advantage of its bulging youth population and push through the hard times of a sluggish economy and few jobs is to provide an environment that encourages youth towards entrepreneurial careers.  Some attendees expressed the need for the curriculum in schools to stoke interest in students.  While this is absolutely a vital part of building an entrepreneurial ecosystem, it is also important to advocate on the policy side as well.

Earlier this year, ICCI won second place in CIPE’s 2012 Leading Practices contest for its efforts to not only increase interest in entrepreneurship, but to advocate for a supportive policy environment.  Being the first chamber in Pakistan to focus on youth development, ICCI created the Youth Entrepreneurship Forum and organized numerous conferences, forums, and seminars inviting youth and university students to attend.  ICCI went a step farther to include policymakers, academics, and young professionals in the events in order to identify existing barriers and craft plausible solutions.  Many of the recommendations that emerged from such events have been adopted by the government and incorporated into the National Youth Policy.

Currently, the Young Entrepreneurs Forum continues to grow and has established connections with universities and other chambers throughout the country.  ICCI also sends youth delegations on international trips to meet with similar youth groups around the world and participate in international forums such as World Chambers Congress.  With the support of CIPE, ICCI has established an Entrepreneurship Development Center that provides aspiring entrepreneurs with access to requisite tools and mentorship.

Through such efforts, ICCI has sparked an amazing interest in entrepreneurship and provides support for those who aspire to start their own enterprises.  Numerous competitions in Pakistan now reward startup teams by matching them with experienced mentors or even helping to secure capital from investors.  But more importantly, ICCI recognizes the importance of also providing a supportive policy environment, a crucial part of any entrepreneurial ecosystem, in which youth have access to the economy.  Regardless of the amount of interest or access to tools and financing youth have, if the environment lacks sound policies, youth will remain excluded and unable to participate in the economy.

Wrapping Up Global Entrepreneurship Week

Tashabos students in Afghanistan celebrating Global Entrepreneurship Week.

“Entrepreneurship thrives where what you know matters more than who you know. Entrepreneurs are natural champions of these ideals; they crave space for creativity and possibility. These aren’t just economic ideals. They are political ideals too. Not just American ideals, but universal ones, and entrepreneurs are among their strongest advocates.” - Thomas Nides, Deputy Secretary of State for Management and Resources, speaking at the Global Entrepreneurship Summit in Washington, DC.

Last week was Global Entrepreneurship Week, which CIPE and partners celebrated here on the blog, on Twitter, and at events around the world.

On November 12, CIPE kicked off the week with a blog post from CIPE Chair Karen Kerrigan discussing why entrepreneurship, and particularly the “entrerpenruial ecosystem,” matters.

At a #GEWChat Twitter chat on Tuesday, November 13, 56 contributors discussed the economic, social, and political importance of entrepreneurship, reaching more than 390,000 people.

In Pakistan, CIPE hosted three major in events in Karachi, Islamabad, and Peshawar. The students at all three events discussed the difficult regulatory environment in Pakistan for start-up businesses, the lack of access to finance, law and order issues, and the discouragement of entrepreneurial risk-taking. Hammad Siddiqui wrote about the importance of supporting the next generation of Pakistani entrepreneurs.

In Latin America & the Caribbean, CIPE partner Revista Perspectiva organized a Spanish-language Twitter chat on entrepreneurship in Latin America. The discussion reached nearly 65,000 Twitter accounts and directly engaged entrepreneurs and thought leaders in the field.

In Afghanistan, an event held in collaboration with the Ministry of Education built awareness of the contributions of young entrepreneurs to Afghanistan’s economy and society. An exhibition at Bibi Sahrah girls’ high school gave 11 students from CIPE’s Tashabos high school entrepreneurship course the opportunity to display crafts and products they have developed and practice their marketing skills.

In Ukraine, CIPE partners hosted events all around the country, including the 5th “Ecoenergy” Youth Festival in Sevastopol.

Entrepreneurship is an especially important topic in the Middle East & North Africa region, where frustration with high youth unemployment and restrictive regulations led to the Arab Spring in 2011. On the blog, Brandon Nickerson discussed some of the barriers young entrepreneurs face in the MENA region and how they can overcome them.

On the blog, contributors also wrote about social entrepreneurship — what it means and how to categorize it.

Learn more about CIPE’s entrepreneurship programs around the world by watching the Prezi below!

Women Entrepreneurs Mark Global Entrepreneurship Week in Pakistan

The Peshawar Women’s Chamber of Commerce and Industry (PWCCI) celebrated Global Entrepreneurship Week with an event held in partnership with CIPE and the Kauffman Foundation on November 15. More than 50 students and lecturers from various Peshawar universities gathered to discuss both the hurdles facing women entrepreneurs in Pakistan, as well as the reasons why the Peshawar region lags behind other parts of the country in producing entrepreneurs. Speaking at the event, PWCCI Vice President Shamama Arbab noted that while young people in Pakistan have no lack of potential, a challenging business climate makes it difficult for them to harness their skills and capabilities.

According to the Global Entrepreneurship Index, Pakistan lags in the number of start-ups, with less than half the rate of early-stage entrepreneurial activity than comparable countries. CIPE Pakistan Deputy Country Director Hammad Siddiqui commented that young Pakistani graduates tend to seek employment in multinationals after graduation, rather than considering the option of entrepreneurship. Furthermore, he noted, “To turn around Pakistan’s economy, women need to participate in the mainstream, including by starting their own businesses.”

During the discussion it was stressed that business development centers should be established to incubate new firms, and that chambers and associations can play a key role in mentoring students who are considering entrepreneurship, as well as new entrepreneurs. The participants emphasized that the government should promote an entrepreneurial culture, and universities should introduce entrepreneurship in the curriculum. The student also noted that the media can play a role in encouraging young people to make their careers in business.

For more information about this event, as well as another event marking Global Entrepreneurship Week in Pakistan held in conjunction with the Young Entrepreneurs’ Forum at the Islamabad Chamber of Commerce and Industry, please see more on the Business Support Organization Forum, an online resource for Pakistani chambers.

Supporting the Next Generation of Entrepreneurs in Pakistan

CIPE Pakistan celebrates Global Entrepreneurship Week.

“Youth have inherent risk-taking ability but do not have the tools and techniques. Our labour force is expanding by 1.5 per cent per annum and there is a great need for job creators rather than job seekers.” Dr Ishrat Husain – IBA Dean and Director
One of the key factors in assessing a business friendly country is to notice the rate of entrepreneurship development. However, the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) Pakistan Report 2010  places Pakistan well below many of its peers in this respect.

According to the GEM report, “The established business ownership rate in Pakistan is 4.7%, which is less than the average rate for factor-driven economies (12.6%).” The report also highlights the fact that since Pakistan’s Independence in 1947 from British India, successive governments focused on the development of large-scale industries both in the public and private sector, and policies to promote entrepreneurship and small businesses were neglected.

Pakistan has some of the best infrastructure, agriculture, and natural resources in South Asia. In addition, there are a number of initiatives from government and donor agencies to boost the entrepreneurial culture.

However, due to the persistent poor law and order situation, weak governance, corruption, bribery, the unavailability of seed capital,  and lack of encouragement from society, the rate of formal business start-ups is the lowest in the region. These issues encourage the growth of the informal sector in Pakistan, which has expanded more rapidly than the formal economy.

The GEM report also highlights following seven challenges being faced by start-ups and small businesses in Pakistan:

CONTINUE READING